So how did we get to the cluster**** we have today between the Jews and Palestinians? Well its complicated, but first off it has nothing to do with the six day war, or the 1948 establishment of the Jewish state, nope its a problem that began some thirty years before Israel became a sovereign nation state. The following will attempt to Explain the origins to the chaos for better understanding and you will see it is not Zionists who are the problem and nor is it the Arabs, yup they are the ones at each others’ throats but neither of them are to blame for this and at the same time both are to blame for the continuation
World War I: The whole sordid mess we have between the Jews and the Palestinians arose during the First World War when Britain and France were seeking to crack the Central Powers and assist Russia which was getting slaughtered by the Germans as a result of bad generalship, a shortage of weaponry, supplies, and munitions, and a chaotic supply system which made these shortages chronic. So to weaken the Central Powers and support Russia against Germany (keep in mind the Turks controlled the Dardanelles and the Hellespont and this prevented allied supply convoys from reaching Russia) the British decided to attack the Ottoman Turks. However, after Gallipoli (the best movie on the subject is the BBC’s All the Kings Men [about the Sandringham Regiment] and I would stay away from Mel Gibson’s Gallipoli] the British found that they could not attack the Turkish homeland directly and would have to go through the Arabian deserts and seize one Turkish province after another and cripple Turkey which would force her to sue for peace and cease to exist as an empire. The British, lest you forget, were bogged down in unending trench warfare France where they were losing tens of thousands of dead, missing, and wounded, per month and could not afford to keep prosecuting the war in France and take on the responsibility of wrecking the Ottoman Turks, which they started to do in 1915 after Turkey joined the Central Powers, without getting assistance and therefore they turned for help where they could get it and naturally they sought the assistance of International Jewry and the Arabs.
Simple Law of Physics, two objects cannot occupy the same space at the same time: Britain needed two things in its war against Turkey- as well as the war in general- money and manpower. The British brought into a common lie of that time which was that international Jewry was exceedingly wealthy and controlled international finance. In addition to this misconception, the British saw the pertinent fact that the World Zionist Conference wanted to have a homeland for Jews to protect the interest of Jewish people everywhere- keep in mind that the early decades of the last century was the high water mark of nationalism (every people group in the world needs its own homeland to protect the interests of that people group)- and although the Jews did not necessarily want what is now Israel (oddly some wanted to have Madagascar which is remarkable considering that is where Hitler originally considered putting them) the British decided that well in ancient times Israel was the Jewish homeland so lets return them. So they decided that if the Jews help us finance our war effort we will allow them to resettle their holy land and this led to the 1917 Balfour Declaration:
Foreign Office,
November 2nd, 1917.
Dear Lord Rothschild,
I have much pleasure in conveying to you, on behalf of His Majesty’s Government, the following declaration of sympathy with Jewish Zionist aspirations which has been submitted to, and approved by, the Cabinet:
“His Majesty’s Government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country”.
I should be grateful if you would bring this declaration to the knowledge of the Zionist Federation.
Yours sincerely
Arthur James Balfour
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balfour…ration_of_1917
While the Jews provided money, it was to be the Arabs -including those who now call themselves Palestinians- who would supply manpower in exchange for the establishment of a multitude of Arab governed sovereign nation states. These promises were assured in open and in secret to the various Arabs including the Palestinians in the McMahon Hussein Correspondence which promised the Palestinians the exact same land as the Jews. Unfortunately for the Arabs the British and French had no intention of following through on their promises in the McMahon/Hussein Correspondance and it was largely ignored during the drafting of the Sykes-Picot Agreement.
Why Sykes-Picot is one of the worst things in the history of this conflict: Well, before the British and French made the Sykes Picot agreement well known the Arabs under Faisal (you remember him as the Arab prince played by Alec Guiness in Lawrence of Arabia) there had been a shot at peace with the signing of the Faisal-Weiszmann Agreement where Faisal basically stated that as long as the Western Powers would allow us to be independent and establish a large Arab state we will allow the Jews to settle without question in Palestine, but if they don’t give us what was agreed to us then we will fight the Jews tooth and nail and kick them out. Well, guess what the British dropped said SYKEs-Picot and then started the ball going. By 1920 the Arabs in Palestine had decided to lash out against the Jewish settlers, whom they saw as nothing but British colonialists and the first Palestinian riots started that year. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riots_in_Palestine_of_1920
The April chaos of 1920, sure enough brought May Riots in 1921 when Jewish Communists in Palestine were conducting a May Day Parade in Jaffa when they were attacked by Palestinians. Then for about seven years there was an uneasy peace between the Jews and Arabs in Palestine but then because of illegal Jewish construction at the wailing wall and Jewish actions which antagonized the Arabs, such as raising the Jewish National flag at the wailing wall, caused tensions to boil over by the end of 1928 and in August, 1929 the crap hit the fan (needed to continue the cliche streak) during the so called Palestine Riots of 1929 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1929_Palestine_riots . To protect themselves from any violence at the hands of the Arabs after the collapse of the Faisal-Weiszmann Agreement in 1920 the Jews established the Haganah which was a paramilitary group which was restrained by Jewish political leaders to only protecting the various Jewish agricultural communes and other settlements. After the horrible riots of 1929 some Jews felt the Haganah was not doing enough to defend Jewish interests and so they established the Irgun which- unlike the Haganah- killed indiscrimenently and very much acted the part of a terror group. The Irgun believed in using terror and violence to achieve their aims and were disliked by the great majority of the Zionist movement. More can be found of the Irgun at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of…ring_the_1930s and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irgun.
The Irgun made an already bad situation in the Mandate of Palestine even worse and their actions exacerbated tensions between Arabs and Jews and all hell broke loose in the 1936 to 1939 Arab Revolt in Palestine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1936%E2…t_in_Palestine During this brutal conflict Jews and Arabs for the first time actively attacked and terrorized each other, and -in a precedent which should show you that partition plans and two state solutions for peace between Israel and Palestine will not work- it led to the first recommendation of a two state solution to the Palestinian conflict. The two state solution (the grandfather of all road map to peace, land for peace, and two state solution schemes to come) was suggested by the Peel commision which sought to establish a Jewish state in the north, A Palestinian state in the south and make Jerusalem and Bethlehem British Mandates. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peel_Commission Ultimately the plan was scrapped as it was rejected outright by the Arabs, caused division amongst the Jews, and was deemed unworkable by the British Government in the findings of the Woodhead Commission http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodhead_Commission. The Woodhead Commission’s findings were equally unpopular with the Palestinians and Zionists (they had three different divisions of the land and all were unpopular to all) and ultimately the British concluded that a two state solution was infeasible.
By 1946 the Holocaust had reinvigorated international plans and talks about the establishment of a Jewish homeland to protect them from ever having to suffer from such a barbaric calamity again. In 1947 the UN, proving in yet another precedent that it would never be able to come up with a lasting peace between Israel and Palestine, established its two state solution and it was widely supported and instantly led to a civil war between the Jews and Arabs that lasted until early 1949.
Conclusion by the Munshaw Commission:
1) Had Anglo-French greed in the signing of the Sykes-Picot agreement not occured the Faisal Weiszmann agreement could have resulted in a much more peaceful twentieth century
2) Foreign intervention and only foreign intervention is to blame for the original and continued failure of peace efforts in that land
3) Two state solutions have never worked and will never work in the holy land and never will. Therefore it is a waste of taxpayer money to try to continue in this nonsense
4) The only thing the Jews and Arabs are to blame for is the escalation and continuance of the violence. Nothing else, neither party started this crap and if the Western world does not quit poking its business into the situation there neither party will be able to end it. The only workable solution at this point would be to drop all military, political, and economic aid to either side until they can agree on their own initiative to develop a lasting peace.
5) I have way too much free time on my hands.
Comments?